Super Lawyers 2022
Avvo Rating 10
National College for DUI Defense
Avvo Clients Choice Award
LC Rated

Judge Criticizes Mandatory Minimum Sentencing Guidelines

Logue Law Group

The headline was enough to cause this West Virginia criminal defense attorney to stop in his tracks. It read, “Judge Regrets Harsh Human Toll of Minimum Mandatory Sentencing.” He had me at “harsh human toll.” Seriously. The story, published by West Virginia Public Broadcasting, provides great background information about how minimum mandatory sentencing came to be – and frames the struggle for balance over keeping communities safe from crime and paying the huge cost of incarceration.

Most interesting to me were the comments made by U.S. District Judge John Gleeson expressing his disapproval of mandatory minimum sentencing. Here’s what he said: “Mandatory minimums, to some degree, sometimes entirely, take judging out of the mix. That’s a bad thing for our system.” I couldn’t agree more. Over the years, I have represented myriad clients who have been charged with federal drug crimes, many of whom were first-time offenders struggling with addiction and in need of help – rehab – to turn their lives around, not stiff mandatory sentences.

But that’s not the judge’s only comment I found to be profound. Here’s an excerpt from the piece: In the current system, only 3 percent of federal cases ever go to trial. He says prosecutors can use the threat of mandatory minimums to coerce guilty pleas and long sentences. “Plea bargains are struck in the United States attorney’s office – nobody sees them happen, there’s no transparency,” Gleeson says. “Transparency in and of itself is a very important value in our system, and we don’t have enough of it. The trials are disappearing.”

Again: As a West Virginia criminal defense lawyer who represents many federal drug clients, I can tell you there are very few that go to trial – and I, too, believe that fear of being convicted and forced to serve a mandatory minimum sentence has a lot to do with it. Sometimes, it’s in the client’s best interest not to take a chance and instead try to negotiate a suitable guilty plea. While a number of lawmakers, experts, and lawyers (myself included) would like to see a change in the mandatory minimum sentencing guidelines, the story indicates that there’s been very little movement on that front.

Source: West Virginia Public Broadcasting – Judge Regrets Harsh Human Toll Of Mandatory Minimum Sentences

Client Reviews

I had hired Mr. Logue a few years ago for my gf at the time for charges she had gotten before I had met her, for prostitution. Big mistake to date her and pay for her lawyer as we didn’t work out but Mr. Logue far exceeded expectations. He got nearly all charges in 2 separate cases dropped for her...

A.C.

I was arrested on a felony 3 charge looking at at least up to 2 years in prison. County District Attorney didn't want to negotiate. After a lot of hard work, Sean was able to plead the case all the way down to just 90 days jail with a work release. Better deal than I realistically could have hoped...

Former Client

Mr. Logue took our son’s cases on very short notice (the first lawyer we hired wasn’t getting anywhere with either of the prosecutors and had actually turned one of the cases over to the court-appointed attorney). We hired Mr. Logue to go to trial if needed, but he worked with both prosecutors and...

Former Client

Get in Touch

Fill out the contact form or call us at (304) 900-3391
to schedule your free consultation.
  1. 1 Free Consultation
  2. 2 Available 24/7
  3. 3 Highly Rated Super Lawyer

Leave Us a Message